The week has past in expectation for what will transpire next week when the Minimum Price regulations are set to come into practice. Exporters are non-the-wiser as to how the price will be set, there does not appear to be a mechanism in place just some assurance that the terminal market will be taken into consideration when setting the levels. Hopefully next week’s report will have a little more information on how this system works!

Meanwhile trading activity has been slow with NY closing lower everyday this week; Prices for red cherry in the South vary between 15 and 20 Birr per kg depending on the area; the crop is starting to come to an end, in Limu washing stations will close next week; in Sidamo, Yirgacheffe and Guji cherries still flow to washing stations but increasingly the focus is on processing Naturals since the flow is much smaller than in December. Volumes traded at ECX continue to trail those of this time last year, it is only a question of time before more volumes arrive to the market (particularly when more Naturals are in the hands of agrabes).

Weather is favourable to drying.

The forex rate is 31.9 to the USD just a whisker away from 32; as mentioned previously, this steady decline that started to accelerate in November is likely to continue until the official rate gets close to the unofficial rate of around 40.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Further confirmation of the low availability of Washed coffee came in the ECX December stocks which reported the lowest Washed coffee stocks in the last 4 years as follows:

This confirms our previous assertions that there was little 18/19 Washed coffee stocks in country; in addition arrivals of New Crop are also very much reduced, resulting in current ECX stocks being 3,000 MT lower than this time last year.

Meanwhile the crop in Guji area is at its peak with coffee ripe and picking heavy; there are some rumours that washing station owners are running short on cash to continue to buy at the current pace due to cash flow restrictions ( last year the price was 12 Birr/kg vs this year 20 Birr/kg) and the hording of processed stocks waiting for further devaluation of the Birr vs the USD before coffee is moved to ECX warehouses and offered for sale. Some stakeholders are expecting the price of cherry to fall next week as there will be less cash in the growing areas and fewer buyers.

Weather continues to favour a healthy development of the crop and processing.

Prices at ECX continue high due to reduced volumes on offer. We expect that at some point soon this situation will normalise and agrabes will start turning coffee into cash so that they can continue to operate at farm gate level.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Last week we made the comment that volumes for sale at ECX were disappointing; below we the compare New Crop arrivals at ECX as of mid-December 2019 vs 2018:

Drilling into the arrivals 2019 vs 2018, the figure that jumps out is the big reduction in Washed Sidamo arriving at ECX, Limu coffees are actually up vs this time last year; Naturals are also down by nearly 50%; overall there is a sharp decrease. The reasons for this situation were highlighted last week.

Turning to Export Prices offered by shippers this week, these were all over the place! With prices offered for standard Sidamo 2 diverging by as much as 60 c/lb… this is a reflection of shippers positions, ECX replacement levels and cherry prices; there seems to be a serious concern about New Crop availability of Sidamo 2 and 4;

Weather continues favour crop development and drying, some washing stations in Sidamo will close next week, since cherry arrivals have started to dwindle in recent days .

Prices for cherry are still very firm in the Southern regions, washing stations are currently paying between 18 and 25 Birr/kg cherry in Sidama, Guji, and Yirgacheffe.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Having sold big volumes into the recent rally shippers are concerned that they cannot cover their more immediate shipments; it is a fact that volumes arriving at the ECX are disappointing and well below what shippers would normally expect to see this time of the year; a combination of weather and economic policy are behind this situation. Firstly,  the unusually wet conditions that had us concerned in November delayed the harvesting and consequently the normal flow to ECX; secondly the government appears to be making no secret of pursuing a strategy of steadily devaluing the  Birr, to reach the black market rate this would require a further devaluation of approx. 8 Birr (Black market rate around 40 birr to the USD), the Birr lost 2 Birr vs USD in the last 2 months. If you are an agrabe it would make sense to delay the sale of coffee in Birr for as long as possible to maximise the Birr price. In this very volatile terminal market, time will tell if this will pay off, for now it would seem that local traders are in the driving seat.

Birr lost 2.5% vs the USD since the beginning of December and 7.5% since the beginning of November.

Weather continues to benefit picking and processing, coffee quality concerns related to humid conditions should not materialise.

Prices for cherry are still very firm in the Southern regions, washing stations are currently paying above 20 Birr/kg cherry in Guji and Yrgacheffe.

Summary of Coffee Ithaka Jimma and Guji tour from 2nd to 13th December

The team travelled extensively to Guji and Jimma coffee zones, in both cases with exporters’ representatives, driving to Guji, passing by Yirgacheffe and Sidamo. In Jimma zone we drove through the coffee producing areas of Limu Kosa and Limu Seqa, among others. We were glad to not have seen any sign of political or socio-economic unrest in both the Southern and Western regions.

Crop Development and Quality

In Guji, coffee cherries are ripe, well-developed and show no signs of disease. Likewise the coffee trees are looking healthy. Crop development and processing:

Naturals: in the last 2 weeks of November, untimely rains fell in Guji zone, however sundried coffee showed no signs of mould damage – we assume farmers and sundried station managers are doing their part by covering during rainy episodes. Same thing for Jimma zone.

Washed: during our trip to Guji the skies were clear. Some parchment was cracked open due to midday sun exposure, which might affect washed coffee quality. In Jimma the weather was hot and the sun was strong, which caused all parchment to crack and to dry in 7 days rather than the ideal 21 days.

For Sidamo region we maintain our 22% reduction in the crop (vs 18/19 crop) published in our October Crop Report, however in Guji, farmers and processing station owners are confident that the 2019/20 crop might be as good as last year’s, despite being an off-year.

In Guji harvesting started 4 weeks ago (mid-Nov) and around 30-35% of the crop is expected to have been harvested to date. In the West, 75% of the Jimma/Limu crop has been  harvested.

Guji cherry Prices

During the team’s trip in Guji coffee zone, 1st week Dec, fresh cherry in Bule Hora and Kercha (West Guji) was being sold between 17 and 20 ETB/kg, giving an FOB Djibouti equivalent of 200 to 235 US ct/lb

by Charles Seara Cardoso

The crop picking and processing is developing well, below our estimate of what has already been picked in the different regions:

Djimma                65-70%

Wellega/Limu    55-60%

Sidamo                 45-50%

Guji                        20-25%

Yrgacheffe          < 20%

Weather has improved over the past week benefitting ripening and drying, in other words, less rain and more sunshine! Our concerns that the weather could impact this season’s quality have greatly diminished in December.

Prices for cherry are still very firm in the Southern regions between 17 Birr and over 20 Birr per kg of cherry; this will keep differentials high, negating the C bull run of recent days and weeks. Shippers are well sold, having taken advantage of the H early push to 125 and now rather cautious and unsure of what prices will have to be paid to cover shorts since only a small volume of the new crop is reaching the market. Current flat priced offers from shippers translate to firm differentials, particularly for washed coffees since many of our suppliers have washing stations or offtake agreements with washing station owners and are seeing cherry prices giving them FOB prices for Sidamo and Guji well over 200 c/lb. Differentially prices for Naturals have decreased considerably in the last 4 weeks however they are now fairly firm considering that the C continues to rally, today Lekempti 5 and Djimma 5 are trading 20 and 24 under May FOB L/C for March/April shipment same as last week.  

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Increased volumes of New Crop are arriving at ECX and therefore most exporters have started offering New Crop for 2020 shipments onwards, Washed coffees are offered for February shipment onwards and Naturals for March onwards, however, we would have to add 1 month to that to be on the safe side! Prices at the ECX are reflected in our price indications below:

 JAN-MARCHMARCH/APRIL ONWARDS
DJIMMAH 5-24-24
LEKEMPTI 5-20-20
DJIMMAH 4-13-13
SIDAMO 4N/A-4
LIMU 2N/A+25
SIDAMO 2N/A+35

The Birr that normally devaluates to the greenback at a fairly constant and steady pace has recently accelerated its devaluation having lost 4% in about 3 weeks:

Weather-wise rains have been less intense than in previous weeks in the Southern coffee-growing region, we continue to monitor the situation; for an explanation of what is going on in East Africa with the weather, the BBC is much better at this us… pls follow the link below:

https://www.bbc.com/weather/features/50680884

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Although the central Government is yet to announce official Referendum results, media outlets have published a figure of 98% in favour of establishing a separate region for Sidama, therefore we are expecting that Sidama will, in time, become the 10th administrative region of Ethiopia; in our view a positive step for harmony within the country. Since the referendum on the 20th of November the area has remained calm and if this is any indication for the upcoming (May 2020) Elections then we are hopeful for that next year’s poll will be a success.

Yet again a wet week in the region, indeed heavy rain in most of East Africa, Djibouti ferried badly with flash floods damaging infrastructure and disrupting port activities. In the coffee growing regions of Ethiopia there was more unseasonal rain, heavy and persistent at times, and increasingly we hear coffee industry stakeholders voicing concerns about the upcoming crop, particularly in the South (Sidamo, Yrgacheffe and Guji) due to rain delaying the crop and impeding normal harvest and primary processing activities; after all we need sun to ripen cherries and to dry parchment/cherries; we have a team visiting the South and West coffee growing regions over the next 2 weeks so will have a clearer idea of the impact weather has had on crop development my mid December.

Prices for cherry have stopped their steady increase and even retreated; we hear that the price being paid in Sidamo is 13 Birr/kg cherry which is a decrease from what was reported last week; the lower price is a consequence of Washing Station owner refusing to pay up as the flow increases and information that the export market will not pay these high prices and this news trickles down to the coffee growing areas ; as more and more washing stations are in the hands of shippers the flow of information and reaction time to market conditions is better and faster. This is a very positive consequence of the liberalisation policies pursued in recent years.

The minimum price policy that has been the focus of much attention in recent weeks is once again being reviewed by the authorities since shippers and other stakeholders have voiced their serious concerns about the measures that had been tabled; therefore we are none the wiser as to what will finally emerge from the Coffee and tea Authority.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

After a delay of a few weeks the Sidamo Referendum was held on Wednesday, 2.2 Million registered voters cast their ballot to decide if the Sidamo area should become an independent region; it is expected that the results will show that Ethiopia is on the path to add a new region to the already existing 9 autonomous regions that make up the country. The ballot was largely peaceful with many people waiting in line for many hours to cast their vote. Official results are expected in a few days’ time. There are other Ethnic groups that are also seeking recognition in other regions so the  challenge for the prime minister will be how to appear to be dealing fairly with all these demands without unleashing tension, that could lead to violence as seen in the recent past. All this is happening 6 months before a General Election, a period when pent up frustrations come to the fore; on a more positive note if the May electoral process emulates what happened on Wednesday the Elections will be a success.

Drier weather this week helping the harvest, bringing on cherry ripening and allowing for coffee to dry once picked and processed.

Cherry Prices seem to be on the up we have reports of prices up to 16 Birr in Sidamo and 18 in Guji; In Yirgacheffe prices are as high as 20 Birr. It seems that if the drier weather continues in the South there will be a flood of cherries to the washing stations, however shippers are concerned that a higher percentage of the crop ill become Naturals rather than Washed coffees; let’s see what happens in the coming weeks. Some fresh coffees from Keffa and Limu have started to appears at the ECX. Also of note is the improvement in Natural quality offered at the ECX in the last 2 or 3 weeks, which has allowed shippers to acquire better quality coffee to fulfil their current commitments. We expect the flow of current crop Naturals to ECX to continue as middlemen need to start focusing on the new crop.

As we have discussed the Ethiopian Coffee & Tea Authority aims to more closely align ECX prices to FOB Djibouti prices, in this regard a minimum price will be set and revised every 15 days, whereby exporters have to register sales at a price above the set minimum price. A further proposal is to punish those that do not follow the regulations, if exporters register a sale below the minimum price by more than 5%, the exporter will, in the first instance, be fined; a second infringement will result in a further penalty and disqualification to register any further contracts at NBE or to purchase coffee from the ECX. Discussions on this regulation are ongoing, we are expecting more news in the next few days.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

Next week we have the long-awaited Referendum that could see the Southern region divided into 2 smaller administrative regions; ongoing rains in the Southern region continues to delay the ripening of the Sidama crop; in Limu, the weather has been dry, the prevailing good conditions are aiding the picking and primary processing of the crop there. The price being paid in Limu is stable and unchanged to last week. Weather in the Sidama area needs to be monitored since the ongoing rains have delayed the ripening of cherries and could disrupt the processing of the crop. The fate of the ECX is again being discussed at the Government level, with reports that a decision will be made by the Prime Minister soon.

Continued sales activity Current Crop Naturals registered at NBE at attractive differentials either side of -20 FOB for D5 and L5 respectively; Exporters that have washing stations are also starting to offer new crop Washed Coffees at similar levels to current Colombia differentials.

by Charles Seara Cardoso

The voter registration process has started for the Referendum that will take place in the Southern Region in 2 weeks’ time; Crop development wise picking is progressing at a slower pace than we had expected a few weeks ago, so far, less than 10% has been picked in Sidama region; in Limu 20-30% has already been picked which in line with our expectations. He price being paid in Limu is around 12 Birr. Weather is normal for this time of the year some rain and plenty of sunshine!

Prices being registered at NBE for Current Crop Naturals in differentials vs. Z Djimma 5 -22 and Lekempti 5 -19; new crop Washed Coffee differentials Limu 2 H+35 and Sidamo 2 a couple of pennies more.

by Charles Seara Cardoso